Lumber Pencil Showdown: Comparing the Best Carpenter Pencils of 2024

By Jane Doe | Published on 2023-03-09

The humble carpenter's pencil, also known as a lumber pencil, is an essential tool for any woodworker or carpenter. With so many options available, it can be challenging to know which one to choose. In this comparison, we'll take a closer look at four popular lumber pencils to help you make an informed decision. From traditional cedar wood pencils to innovative mechanical options, we'll highlight the key features of each product and weigh up their pros and cons. So, whether you're a seasoned pro or just starting out, read on to discover the right lumber pencil for you.

What to look for:

award icon Our ranking

* Prices may vary depending on promotions and sellers' choices.

RevMark Carpenter Pencil 24 Pack White with Red Lead and Printed Ruler, Made in The USA. Quality Cedar Wood for Carpenter...

Price: $   20.99 *

Welcome to our review page for the RevMark Carpenter Pencil 24 Pack! This pack of pencils is perfect for carpentry work, with a unique white color and red lead for easy visibility on dark surfaces. Additionally, the pencils feature a printed ruler for added convenience on the job. Made in the USA with quality cedar wood, these pencils are sure to impress. Dive in and see what other customers have to say about the RevMark Carpenter Pencils!


DIXON Industrial Carpenter Pencils, Medium, Black and Silver, 6-Pack, (14206)

Price: $   8.4 *

Looking for the perfect carpenter pencils to make your projects easy and efficient? Look no further than the DIXON Industrial Carpenter Pencils. With a medium thickness and stylish black and silver design, these pencils are the perfect addition to any professional or DIYer's tool kit. This 6-pack is sure to last you through multiple projects, and the unique graphite formula ensures a smooth and consistent line every time. Keep reading for our in-depth review of the DIXON Industrial Carpenter Pencils.


Markal 106 Marker Holder for Carpenter's Pencil and Lumber Crayon, 5" Length (Pack of 12)

Price: $   133.34 *

Welcome to our product review page for the Markal 106 Marker Holder! Are you tired of constantly losing your carpenter's pencil or lumber crayon? Look no further than the Markal 106 Marker Holder, which not only keeps your writing utensils secure, but also provides a comfortable grip while you work. In this review page, we will dive into the features and benefits of this handy tool, as well as provide feedback from customers who have tried it out for themselves. If you're a carpenter or someone who frequently works with wood, you won't want to miss out on this product!


Swanson Tool Co CP216 AlwaysSharp Refillable Mechanical Carpenter Pencil, Two Pack, with 8 More Replacement Black Graphite...

Price: $   0 *

Looking for a reliable and long-lasting mechanical carpenter pencil? Look no further than the Swanson Tool Co CP216 AlwaysSharp Refillable Mechanical Carpenter Pencil. With its easy-to-use design and multiple refills included in each pack, this pencil is perfect for any project. Read on for a detailed review of this top-quality product.


* Prices may vary depending on promotions and sellers' choices.


After researching and comparing various carpenter pencils, the Lumber Pencil stands out as a high-quality and durable option. The RevMark Carpenter Pencil and Swanson Tool Co CP216 AlwaysSharp Refillable Mechanical Carpenter Pencil offer unique features, such as printed rulers and refillable graphite, respectively. However, the Lumber Pencil's simplicity and traditional design make it a staple in any carpenter's toolkit. Additionally, its quality cedar wood and strong lead make it a reliable and long-lasting option. Overall, the Lumber Pencil is a top choice for any carpentry project.